I too was skeptical about the fun that would be had in a tinny with a couple of guns and torps. I was however intrigued enough by this niche and the excitement of fast boats with large explosive bits tacked onto them to check it out.
I have always liked the idea and the mean muscle car look of PT boats.
When I played the demo, it all seemed very simple and elegant to play. It kept surprising me with how rich the features were and how fun it actually was to speed around the big boats.
Essentially if you ever wanted to command a battleship, this is the smaller, faster sexier version of that. The missions should be short and exciting, I am also looking forward to seeing the shoreline that a lot of the missions are "purported" to take place in. Cat and mouse in and out of inlets should be a blast.
There is so much potential here, but I guess you really have to like the concept of fast attack boats used for scouting, recon, spy insertion, raiding shipping, harrassment, escort duty, massed attacks, ground support and insertion.
Certainly today patrol boats have a major role - the torpedoes - in border protection, interception etc... in PT boats Knights of the sea, I'd like to see a lot of merchant interceptions and cargo searches.
I know their are missions where shore bases seem to be raided by torpedoe boats, and they are perfect for jumping in and out of temp harbours or bases and creating havoc with mines and depth charges
A major problem with PT boats however seems to be their obvious frailty and their exposure to aircraft. They are however small targets with a lot of AA guns. And the short missions they go on should not leave them too far from cover. You can pretty much outrun anything in them (aircraft notwithstanding) including larger vessels with the same speed rating. This is due to high top speed combined with maneover speed.
And yes I did like Michael's Navy.
I remember an American President had his PT boat the 109 chopped in half by a japanese destroyer?
I understand its not for everybody and really have to play the demo more before a verdict.
What does surprise me is the lack of interest in PT boats - mosquito navy in general.
I know that in ww2 the largest warship destroyed was by the Italians in the HMS Sheffield - a cruiser. And the the German Torp Boats (I think S-boats) only destoryed about 200 merchants during the war. But still I think its interesting, dangerous - no skulking in the depths like a scaredy cat ;) and downright fun spinning around with overpowered power to weight ratios.
P.S. Like mechwarrior I reckon a ww2 recon platoon simulator would be downright smashing too. Imagine driving a sdkz 232 or a m3 HT down the road to scout enemy positions and report back. Imagine all those reverse gears you would have to use while probing in and out of enemy positions. I think this could be a lot more engaging than a simple assault. Armed Recon in a armoured car could be great fun!
I mean you know your going to hit the front line, enemy recon units or forward elements at some point... while trying to find the main or ur objective enemy units. MAybe even scouting and reporting locations and tactics of new units (methinks king tigers first appearance in the field)
<message edited by destraex on Monday, November 09, 2009 7:22 PM>