The Wargamer's Guide to...The Best Naval War Games

[CrazyOkie]

Silent Service II? Maybe that's just for us oldies

definitely a golden oldie. This list seems dedicated only to current titles. If we were going for true HOF games, I'd list the original Harpoon, SS2, 688 Attack Sub, Red Storm Rising, Pacific General, and my favorite of all time, Carrier Strike (a Gary Grigsby game!). Surprised not to see the Kriegsmarine DLC for Order of Battle.

[McHugh]

What I noticed about the above list is that most of them are arcade style games which I am not interested in.

[AP514]

Flat Top.(AH).I had and still might have it some place.
I had the SSI version Carrier Strike (PC/Com 64)
then I had the Carriers at War old version, then the newer Matrix one(they did not do much to it. Better Graphics) but still did not fix the FOW (you could find the enemy CV real Easy just send out searchers and the zone that did not report back was where Enemy CV was.

+1 for Silent Hunter 5 should definitely go on the list...with the Wolves of Steel mod
A great purchase for only 5 bucks. KINGUIN.com

Naval Action --a better battle Sim(was a tester/beta) than it is a large open world game(as it is Now)

[SundiataWTF]

Please stop including games that can't be easily obtained in your "Best" lists. It is frustrating to see Supremacy at Sea here when it requires a disc drive (no download option). It should be moved to the Hall of Fame.

[EICJoe]

Please stop including games that can't be easily obtained in your "Best" lists. It is frustrating to see Supremacy at Sea here when it requires a disc drive (no download option). It should be moved to the Hall of Fame.

Fair point, I'll look into it for the next update.

[AP514]

Please stop including games that can't be easily obtained in your "Best" lists. It is frustrating to see Supremacy at Sea here when it requires a disc drive (no download option). It should be moved to the Hall of Fame.

You interested in it..I have a disk.....

[AP514]

Carrier Battles 4 Guadalcanal...I am liking this one..
Very Fun and having a good time with multiplayer.