Since the 1970s, tabletop roleplaying games have enticed players with their promise of memorable, paper- and dice-scattered evenings, using the magic of shared imagination to summon up heart-racing adventure. There’s a tabletop RPG out there for every taste, theme, genre, or setting you could want – trust us – so we’ve created this guide to track the absolute best tabletop RPGs on offer.
Let’s get this out of the way early: yes, DnD 5e and Pathfinder are here – they may be old hat to some, but they’re both excellent games that absolutely deserve a spot at the top table. This guide goes beyond those big names, though, to track the best tabletop RPGs across all walks of roleplaying life – big, small, old, and new.
We’ll cover choices for veterans and newcomers, quick one-shots and lengthy campaigns, and detail the unique features that set each killer RPG apart from the rest. Because we at Wargamer like a good scare, you’ll find a fair few horror RPG games in the mix – so beware!
Of course, if you are looking to go dungeoneering in the big kahuna of TTRPGs, we can help. Our DnD classes, DnD races, and DnD backgrounds guides can help you craft a character, and then you’ll need a good DnD character sheet to tell their story with. For now, though…
The best tabletop RPGs in 2023 are:
- Blades in the Dark – the best crime tabletop RPG
- Night Witches – the best historical tabletop RPG
- Cyberpunk 2020 – the best cyberpunk tabletop RPG
- Mouse Guard – the most adorable tabletop RPG
- Warhammer 40k: Wrath & Glory – the best Warhammer 40k TTRPG
- Legend of the Five Rings – the best samurai tabletop RPG
- Mörk Borg – the tabletop RPG with the best art
- Cy_Borg – the best neon colored tabletop RPG
- Dread – the best tabletop RPG with no dice
- Call of Cthulhu 7e – the best Lovecraft tabletop RPG
- Star Wars Roleplaying Game – the best tabletop RPG with Wookiees
- Dungeons and Dragons 5e – the Coca-Cola of tabletop RPGs
- Pathfinder – the best mechanically detailed tabletop RPG
- Ten Candles – the best horror tabletop RPG
- The One Ring – the best Lord of the Rings tabletop RPG
Blades in The Dark
The best crime tabletop RPG
Blades in The Dark is a twisted 19th-century heist game where players take on the role of scoundrels, looking to complete ‘scores’ with their crew. Set in the fictional gothic, industrial city of Doskvol, the RPG launches you into an exciting crime-caper gameplay style, having you face off with rival crews while avoiding the law.
At the same time, you must try to survive volatile Victorian back alleys, where ghosts roam, and lowlife citizens are ready to stab you in the back. But despite its exciting setting and enjoyable heist movie tropes, what truly makes the game so successful is its fast, easy-to-pick-up game mechanics and unique character choices.
From its ‘flashback’ system to the option to play as a ghost after a character’s death, Blades in The Dark constantly rewards you for inventive roleplay and imaginative thinking, while requiring little setup preparation. Working for both one-shots and lengthy campaigns, this RPG will suit those seeking to get stuck into a detailed story, with minimal prep time.
The best historical tabletop RPG
Creator Jason Morningstar (the designer behind popular card-driven storytelling game Fiasco) has splashed a heavy mix of history and combative tension into this WWII tabletop RPG.
In Night Witches, you and your friends will play as pilots in the Soviets’ famed all-woman air force, bombing Nazis during the night and navigating the politics and relationships of the male-dominated Red Army by day.
Although most RPGs are now accessible for first-timers, if you are a history buff, or a fan of digital WW2 games, looking to pitch into your first tabletop experience, Night Witches is really one of the best you can find.
The game has two distinctive modes built into its night-and-day cycle. At night, you engage in deadly aerial combat, making strategic decisions as a team to complete missions in your two-person aircraft. During the day, you are a roleplaying master, avoiding NKVD interrogation and getting ready for the next night’s combat sorties.
Night Witches makes it easy to figure out if you prefer combat-heavy or narrative-focused RPGs, since it ably simulates both styles – letting your group discover what kind of roleplayers they truly are, all while enjoying the game’s strikingly well-done war story.
The best cyberpunk tabletop RPG
Meet the 33-year-old tabletop RPG that inspired 2020’s biggest videogame release, Cyberpunk 2077. Cyberpunk 2020 brings you all the gritty, neon style and action that have carved out this genre’s spot in mainstream popular culture for many years. The game is fast, pretty brutal and all about those stylish, 1980s retro-futuristic aesthetics.
Players can take on a number of classic cyberpunk tropes, choosing from classes including the world-hacking netrunner, Mad Max-esque nomad and more. With cyberware, mechanics for losing your very humanity, and a terrifyingly detailed world, the Cyberpunk RPG is full of narrative potential, offering tons of dystopian inspiration for both players and GMs to sink their teeth into.
The game also has some of the best combat roleplaying you can find. Every confrontation in Cyberpunk 2020 is fast and cinematic, making it easy to live out your Blade Runner fantasy.
Plus, your character won’t suddenly make a T-pose and jump 100 feet in the air during a casual motorbike ride, or project their genitals through their trousers midway through a key narrative scene. You know, unless that’s something your group’s into. We don’t judge.
The most adorable tabletop RPG
Probably the cutest entry on our list, Mouse Guard throws you into the charming world of David Petersen’s award-winning comic book series of the same name. In a world with no humans, mice have built a medieval European civilisation, which is continuously under threat from predators, an underground weasel syndicate and even the weather.
Players become Mouse Guards: rangers that protect the territories across Mousedom, fighting in the wilderness, leading wars and interacting with other adorable townsfolk.
The game engine uses the Burning Wheel roleplaying system, which makes the character creation and combat portions feel incredibly detailed and (to be honest) requires a bit of a learning curve. Thankfully, the Sourcebook offers step by step guides, solving tons of questions that new players might have, all while treating them to Petersen’s phenomenal illustrations on every page.
Mouse Guard has you take on the role of a very small hero facing a giant world, amplifying the hero’s journey narrative that we all know and love when playing RPGs. It’s a game for everyone, easy to pick up, and one that (once you get used to the system) can be shared with the whole family.
Warhammer 40,000: Wrath and Glory
The best Warhammer 40k tabletop RPG
Having grown continuously from its beginnings as a miniatures wargame in 1987, Warhammer 40k is understandably massive, full of depth and (let’s face it) pretty intimidating for newcomers. However, Cubicle 7’s licensed standalone RPG, Warhammer 40,000: Wrath and Glory, is perhaps the best introduction to 40k’s gargantuan setting.
Set in the 41st millennium, with the militaristic techno-fascist Imperium of Mankind in control, humanity finds itself in a perpetual war against all the galaxy’s xenos races, as well as countless renegade human factions, and worse besides. If you like sci-fi with dark stories and heavy themes, and are ok with basically playing as a villain whatever you do, then Warhammer 40k will be right up your alley.
Wrath and Glory takes place in one solar system, with a live, local storyline already in the offing, making roleplay feel more focused and letting players fully explore what the Warhammer 40k setting can offer, without feeling overwhelmed by an entire galaxy full of lore to contend with right away.
It also comes with an updated D6 dice mechanic replacing the previous Warhammer percentile system, making general combat and checks easier, faster and more user-friendly.
Legend of The Five Rings
The best samurai tabletop RPG
Fantasy Flight’s Legend of The Five Rings RPG (set in the same universe as the Legend of the Five Rings card game) lets players take the role of a disciplined samurai in a world full of territorial rivalry and Asian-inspired mythos. Picking one from seven clans, you face off in duels, fight massed battles, and slay demons in the pursuit of domination and honour.
At its core, it’s a cinematic RPG that prioritises character building and extreme detail, meaning it can be a challenge for GMs to initially keep track of – but it’s truly one of the most rewarding RPGs for character-centric players. The game also has a unique elemental attribute system that puts a spin on typical checks and gameplay choices.
However, given all the information you need to absorb, if you aren’t a fan of fantasy, the feudal Japanese aesthetic, or rampant orientalism, this probably isn’t the game for you.
On the other hand, if you’re a lover of mythology, a player who forms unhealthy attachments to your characters or loves strategically building them up, Legend of The Five Rings will most likely become a fast favourite.
The tabletop RPG with the best art
Let’s make one thing clear: you’re going to die. A self-described doom metal album of a game, Mörk Borg ain’t for the faint of heart – in its apocalyptic world, the rules are light and the consequences for simply existing are heavy.
Created by a couple of ingenious, deeply disturbed Swedes named Pelle Nilsson and Johan Nohr, Mörk Borg is filled with serpent-worshipping cultists, insidious cannibals and deadly miseries. GMs roll daily to determine if a horrifying prophecy will be fulfilled, and once seven have occurred it’s game over.
If you’re thinking this sounds like the bleak, macabre, occult energy of a scandi horror flick, in RPG form, you aren’t far off. With its dark aesthetics, medieval nordic setting and headbanging character classes like ‘heretical priest’, it’s pretty much guaranteed that if you’re a fan of heavy metal music, you’re going to be a fan of Mörk Borg.
It’s an RPG trimmed of all the fat, hyper-focusing on core elements that make tabletop roleplaying fun. Combat is fast, and players only have four stats, with no throwaway abilities cluttering up their sheets. Anyone can use magic via sacred scrolls, and the game’s rules are loose enough to encourage freewheeling and hilarious roleplay.
The best neon colored tabletop RPG
The gruesome system behind Mörk Borg was so good that it couldn’t be contained by just one setting. Cy_Borg takes you from dark dungeons to a sci-fi dystopia filled with capitalist-hating punks. Miseries still plague the world, but this time they come in the form of bio-bombings, toxic tsunamis, and cy-rage.
If you wished Mörk Borg had more guns, drones, and cybernetic enhancements, Cy_Borg will be right up your street. It’s also an excellent choice for lovers of sci-fi who like to keep things simple.
Many science fiction games are weighed down by dense lore and (often overly) complex mechanics. Cy_Borg may be punishing to play, but it’s a rules-light game that’s simple to learn and offers a streamlined sci-fi experience. Even creating characters can be done with minimal work: if you want to, you can put your fate in the hands of the dice and roll up a random Punk that’s still unique and suitably revolting.
The best tabletop RPG with no dice
Not every tabletop RPG relies on dice rolls. The perfect example of this is Dread, a horror roleplaying game that forces players to pull blocks from a Jenga tower every time they face a challenge. Remove the block, and you get to see another day; if the tower falls, you’re dead and dusted.
A game of Dread can take place in any setting, but the game master should try to place players in situations where death is a very likely possibility. The physical tension of trying to keep a Jenga tower standing adds incredible weight to suspenseful roleplay situations – if you want players on the literal edge of their seats, this is the way to do it.
Like many classic horror flicks, Dread’s character options are typically divided into archetypes (think Jocks and Nerds). You’ll get a chance to make them your own, though, as a series of curated questions during character creation will flesh out who your character is, as well as what they’re capable of in dire situations.
Call of Cthulhu 7e
The best Lovecraft tabletop RPG
A cosmic horror and investigative saga that will almost certainly end in your character going insane, Call of Cthulhu 7e is one of the most well-known and beloved tabletop RPGs on the market.
Originally published by Chaosium in 1981, the game takes place in the world of H.P. Lovecraft’s endlessly popular cosmic horror novels, and turns players into investigators, travelling through a 1920s setting full of paranormal and mind-bending mysteries.
If you like great battle-axe-wielding characters and solving your RPG challenges via brawny combat, Call of Cthulhu probably isn’t going to be your cup of tea. Playing as a squishy investigator, you won’t so much be fighting hulking monsters, as engaging in a battle of wits with them, rolling desperate, quick-thinking skill checks to escape their clutches. The rules can get detailed, but Call of Cthulhu is a must-play for horror fans.
It’s also worth noting that even if you don’t succumb to Lovecraftian madness, you will probably die nonetheless, making it the perfect game for one-shots, or groups who love getting to grips with an RPG’s rules through multiple playthroughs – and don’t mind rolling up multiple new eccentric turn-of-the-century weirdos over the course of a campaign, to replace the characters lost to the Great Old Ones’ machinations.
Star Wars Roleplaying Game
The best tabletop RPG with Wookiees
Another Fantasy Flight title, the Star Wars Roleplaying Game has you step into a galaxy far far away, joining a crew of heroes travelling the (apparently incurably) war-torn galaxy that once belonged to George Lucas.
The game is broken up into three distinct modules: Age of Rebellion, Edge of the Empire and Force and Destiny. Age of Rebellion sees you taking up the insurrectionist cause, becoming a rebel fighter in their guerilla war against the Empire. Force and Destiny (if the name didn’t clue you in) treads the Jedi path, having your characters learn the way of the force. Finally, in Edge of the Empire, you take your cues from Han Solo or Boba Fett, smuggling, bounty hunting, and essentially swindling your way across the Outer Rim.
No matter which of these games you choose, they’re smoothly compatible with one another, as they all share the same core rules and mechanics, meaning you can easily cross over between the modules and engage with the ‘full experience’ – if your wallet can stretch to all three sourcebooks. The general game mechanics are simple, and perfectly capture the fast-moving, unrestrained gameplay you’d expect from a Star Wars RPG.
Dungeons and Dragons 5e
The Coca-Cola of tabletop RPGs
We can’t be forgetting the noble, nearly half-century-old granddaddy of all RPGs, now, can we? Often credited as the original tabletop RPG, Dungeons & Dragons has thrived for decades and seemingly just gets better and better with every instalment.
Combining strategy with some flashy magic and charismatic heroes, sword-and-sorcery folks searching for a fantasy-based RPG will struggle to find a better all-rounder than this stone-cold classic. With easy character creation reminiscent of the first edition, and simplified game mechanics, D&D 5e feels both retro and entirely novel.
Although long-time players may be itching for more stringent rules, there is no denying Dungeons and Dragons 5e’s mass appeal. With faster combat, increased immersion, and more space for imaginative storytelling, it’s understandable why this edition is the most-played version of D&D to date.
If you are looking to get into tabletop RPGs for the first time – or a budding Game/Dungeon Master, keen to make your first homebrew campaign in a flexible environment where inspiration, tried-and-tested structures and ready-made assets are all plentiful, D&D is a superb place to start.
With a straightforward game system and vast, yet accessible fantasy worlds, it’s easy to get inspired and excited, as you launch into adventures full of battle-scarred orcs, bloodcurdling monsters, and flamboyant sorcerers.
The best mechanically detailed tabletop RPG
Pathfinder is a Paizo tabletop RPG that was originally a modified version of D&D 3.5e. However, in the years since the first edition, Pathfinder has grown into its own game with its own identity and dedicated fanbase.
Pathfinder is for gamers who love crunch, real crunch. It’s got heaps and heaps of Pathfinder classes, Pathfinder races, spells, and other player options – to the point where Pathfinder character sheets start to look a little stuffed.
This can be a little overwhelming at first, but the reams of rulebook eventually give you an enormous amount of freedom. The level of detail in every character, magic item, and adventure makes each level up more satisfying than the last.
The best horror tabletop RPG
Cavalry Games’ Ten Candles is, hands-down, one of the most atmospheric games we’ve ever played. A one-shot-only game, sessions take place in a dark room, with ten candles providing the only source of light.
At least, that’s how the game starts. The candles aren’t just there to set the mood; they’re a core part of the RPG’s mechanics. Players have a communal pool of d6s they must roll any time they face a conflict. If the roll fails, a candle goes out. When the party are down to their final candle, the group must narrate how they die. They can choose to burn the paper they’ve written parts of their character on to improve their chances, but Ten Candles only ever ends one way: darkness and death.
Storytelling comes before everything in Ten Candles. The rules are very light, and the Game Master doesn’t have sole control of the narrative. They’ll often be rolling against the players, with the winner getting to narrate the outcome of a roll.
If you’ve only ever played games like D&D, Ten Candles can be a little jarring at first. The social contract between DM and players is totally different, and there’s no real way to ‘win’ a scenario or build a powerful character. However, if you love telling a good (but grim) tale, you can’t do better than Ten Candles.
The One Ring
The best Lord of the Rings tabletop RPG
The One Ring‘s gorgeous art and production would make it a great coffee-table book for any fan of Lord of the Rings, but we highly recommend playing it too. Free League has lovingly recreated the land of Eriador and stuffed the rules with enough Tolkien lore to make die-harders squee. Ever wished you could spend more time with Tom Bombadil in the original trilogy? The One Ring gives you that chance.
That being said, this isn’t a Silmarillion-level reading task. There’s enough background info to get you started without being too heavy, and the system (which relies on d6s and d12s) is pretty approachable without being overly rules-light.
One of our favourite things about The One Ring is the additional, non-combat rules it provides. While Lord of the Rings has some truly epic battles, these aren’t the only important events that take place. The One Ring provides detailed rules for journeys, social encounters, and creating story-changing magic items.
This is a game for great (if unexpected) journeys. Your gaggle of humans, elves, dwarves, and hobbits will find their own way to fight back against The Shadow – as long as they can hold off its dark influence over their hearts.